Thursday, April 28, 2016

Explosive Reactive Armor - some history, some types

Explosive Reactive Armor (ERA) is a type of modern special armor. ERA is formed by using one or multiple layers of high explosive between armor plates.
ERA can be manufactured as add-on armor or integrated into the armor of a vehicle. Add-on ERA usually consists of a smaller tiles or boxes, which are attached to the vehicle by bolts. The use of smaller tiles reduces weakspots once the ERA has been detonated.

The working mechanism of ERA, patent drawing from Dr. Held
The working mechanism of the most common types of ERA follows a very simple design. A layer of high explosives is sandwiched between two metal plates, together this is forming a reactive element. When being penetrated by a shaped charge jet or another projectile, the high explosives will detonate and propell the two metal plates into opposing directions. This has two effects: more mass (metal) is moved into the path of the projectile and the converse movement of the metal plates will have a disrupting effect on the projectile, shattering the shaped charge jet.
To properly work however, the reactive element has to be inclined in relation to the penetration path of the shaped charge jet.
Heavy ERA is able to destroy or at least damage modern armor-piercing ammunition like the long-rod penetrators used in APFSDS ammunition.

The Bradley IFV is a prime example for bad ERA coverage
However ERA has in general a number of drawbacks:
  • ERA is expended after one hit, leaving an exposed area on the tanks surface
  • ERA can be detonated by precursor charges and other projectiles
  • most types of ERA don't provide protection against tandem charge ammunition
  • fragments from ERA are spread over a larger area, increasing collateral damage

On the drawback of poor coverage of a vehicles surface with ERA, the Swedish FMV came to the conclusion that in case of the T-80U the Kontakt-5 ERA should be considered "50% protection", because only about half of the frontal surface is actually covered by the ERA.

According to Russian sources, the Soviets started their earliest research in explosive (reactive) armor in 1949. However the whole Soviet ERA development ended without success or the adoption of any type of ERA, following poor design choices and accidents.
The ERA in the form as known today was invented - or popularized in the case one values the fruitless Soviet developments high - by the German researcher Dr. Manfred Held. Dr. Manfred Held traveled to Israel following the Six-Day War. He was an expert for shaped charge warheads and wanted to examine the effects of shaped charges on real Soviet-made tanks, like the ones used by the Arab nations in the Six-Day War. Following his investagions of damaged T-54 and T-55 tanks, he discovered in some cases, the detonation of ammunition has reduced the damaged caused by the shaped charge warhead. He developed a first type of working ERA and patented it in 1970 (German patent 2053345). This original ERA also provided protection against kinetic energy penetrators like APDS and APFSDS, but was impractical and complicated compared to more modern designs. It was designed as integrated ERA, which required the vehicle to have special cavities into which the reactive element and explosive was inserted.
Held then patented (German patent 2008156) a more refined version of ERA in the same year, which happens to be very comparable to modern ERA, consisting of a tile formed by two thin steel plates with an explosive material sandwiched inbetween.
While not having any success in persuading Germany or other NATO members to adopt his developments, things changed when Dr. Held came back to Israel in 1974 for further research following the Yom-Kippur War. After he presented his invention to a delegation of the IDF, the Israeli government issued Rafael to develop a type of ERA for series production.

The first type of explosive reactive armor adopted on a tank was Blazer ERA. Blazer used a rather primitve construction using one reactive element per tile. Each reactive element consisted of a three milimeter steel plate, a three milimeter thick layer of explosives and a further three milimeter thick steel plate. Blazer was first deployed in the Lebanon War of 1982.
Cross section of Blazer ERA mounted on a M48 Patton tank. Two reactive elements are bolted onto the steel case.
Blazer ERA uses an insensitive explosive filler, which does not detonate upon penetration by small arms and medium caliber ammunition up to 23 mm AP. Upon penetration by a shaped charge jet, the steel plates accelerate to a velocity of approximately 800 meters per second. Blazer ERA could reduce the penetration of an RPG-7 projectile from 300 to about 100 milimeters into steel, although the absolute figures are depending on the angle of impact.
IDF M60 tank fitted with Blazer ERA
However Blazer in it's original form had a number of drawbacks. It provided rather poor coverage on many vehicles (including the M48, M60 and Centurion tanks), leaving unprotected gaps in the layout. Due to using many different shapes of ERA tiles, Blazer was a logistical burden compared to other types of ERA.
The Slovenian M-55 upgrade used (Super Blazer) ERA for protection.

Blazer has been succeded by the Super Blazer ERA in the 1990s/2000s. Aside from being more effective than it's predecessor, Super Blazer also offers some amount of protection against kinetic energy penetrators and is not being initiated by KE ammunitions up to 23 mm AP and fragments from artillery and mortar rounds detonating as close as 2 metres away.

The Soviet Union was the second country to adopt explosive reactive armor in form of their Kontakt ERA, which was first introduced in 1984. In most forms Kontakt ERA uses two reactive elements, although there might have been versions with just one reactive element. The reactive elements are located in rather small boxes (314 x 148 mm base area) with three milimeter thick steel walls. The reactive sandwich with the designation 4S20 consists of a 2 mm thick steel plate, a 7 mm thick explosive and a 2 mm thick steel plate. A Kontakt ERA tile with two reactive sandwich plates has a weight of 5.7 kilograms without attachment bolts. About 151 tiles are used for a tank (although the number varies depending on tank type and surface area).
Kontakt-1 ERA tile showing the arrangement of the two elements.
Just like Blazer, the original Kontakt ERA did not provide any protection against armor-piercing ammunition and used insensitve explosives in order to prevent the detonation by small arms fire.
According to Russian sources, Kontakt ERA provides protection equivalent to up to 400 mm rolled steel armor (RHA) when hit by single-stage shaped charge warheads. Unlike Blazer, Kontakt provides protection at a greater amount of angles, because of the use of two reactive elements aligned at different angles. The smaller size of the Kontakt tiles is also favorable.

Kontakt-5 was the Soviet follow-up development to the original Kontakt ERA, which was designed to also provide protection against armor-piercing ammunition. Unlike the previous generation of Kontakt ERA, Kontakt-5 was considered "integrated ERA" by the Soviets, because of the mounting mechanism and the. Kontakt-5 is a type of heavy ERA.
Kontakt-5 uses a heavy steel shell, into which the 4S22 reactive element is inserted. Depending on where the tile is used, one or two reactive elements are installed. The 4S22 reactive elements are using more powerful explosive fillers with a TNT equivalency of 0.33 kilograms compared to the 0.28 kilograms of the earlier 4S20 reactive element of Kontakt-1.
Kontakt-5 armor layout and 4S22 tiles
Nii Stali claims that Kontakt 5 ERA provides protection equivalent to 400-500 mm steel against RPGs and ATGMs, 200-250 mm steel against HEAT tank and artillery ammunition, and reduces the penetration of APFSDS by 20%. This is said to increase the armor protection of the T-72B by factors 1.2 against APFSDS and 1.9-2.0 against shaped charges. Nii Stali also claimed that a T-55 eqiupped with Kontakt-5 ERA is able to resist APFSDS ammunition with up to 400 mm penetration.
Kontakt-5 provides protection against APFSDS by using a combination of more powerful explosives charges and thick coverplates - this results in shattering of the penetrator or bending of the rod. However more modern types of APFSDS can defeat Kontakt-5 ERA without being destroyed or strongly deformed.

The DYNA reactive armor was developed 1988 by the Czech military repair facility in Novy Jicin together with the military technical institue of Slavicin. Unlike the previous mentioned types of reactive armor, DYNA does not use reactive elements formed by simple steel plates with explosives sandwiched inbetween, but rather uses rhombus shaped elements (◊).  These consist of a thin-walled hollow steel rhombus which is coated with a layer of explosives. The explosvies are covered by another thin steel layer.
Each ERA tile for the frontal armor of the local T-72M4Cz versions holds a number of rhombus shaped elements. Based on photographs it appears to be up to five rhombi in a DYNA tile
DYNA reactive armor showing the ◊-shaped steel and the explosive filler (white)
According to figures from the Czech military, when mounted onto a T-72M1 the protection is increased to 1.3 times the original protection against APFSDS, and to 2.2 to 2.7 times the original protection against RPGs and missiles.
The construction of the DYNA reactive armor used for protection the tank's roof and hull might be different, at least the thickness of the used ERA modules is different.

Nozh and Duplet reactive armor have been developed in the Ukraine. Instead of just using explosive materials sandwiched between simple steel plates, the Ukrainian engineers decided on using several linear shaped charges (LCS). The LCSs consist of either copper or aluminium and have a classic "half moon" shape [☾]. In the hollow center section, high explosives are inserted. 
Upon penetration, the explisve filler of the linear shaped charges will detonate and accelerate the liner material. This will form a shaped charge jet (or rather a bar), just like in a convential shaped charge as used on HEAT warheads.
Different reactive elements for Nozh and Duplet ERA.
Unlike many other types of ERA, the Duplet ERA consist of many different layers ontop of each other, the space between the different ERA layers is partly covered by solid steel elements. In case of the T-84M Oplot-M main battle tank, there are up to three layers of Duplet ERA at the turret and the hull sides, whereas the glacis armor utilizes only two layers.
Thai T-84M Oplot-M with three ERA layers at the turret front
As a result of Duplets multi-layer design - consisting of up to three reactive armor tiles sandwiched spaced by rather heavy, solid blocks of steel - Duplet ERA cannot be utilized on small and lightweight vehicles.Per square metre Duplet ERA weighs between 400 and 500 kilograms.
According to figures provided by the Ukranian manufacturer, Nozh and Duplet provide between 1.5 and 2.5 times as much protection as the "best world analogues" like Kontakt-5 and Blazer. Other, even more questionable figures from Ukranian sources claim that Duplet can reduce the penetration of unknown types of single stage shaped charge, tandem shape charge warheads and APFSDS by up to 90%. These values are most likely propganda or based on completely obsolete ammunition - the combat performance of Ukranian T-64 and T-72 tanks has been rather poor, despite using Nozh ERA.

The Polish ERAWA reactive armor is designed for extended coverage of the tank's suface in comparision with other ERA solutions. The tiles are quadratic and smaller than those of the previously mentioned ERA types. This means that ERAWA ERA tiles can be fitted to a tank nearly "seamless".

The ERAWA-2 tile and layout
ERAWA-2 is a multilayer ERA version of ERAWA, using two reactive elements in one tile. This provides higher protection against shaped charge warheads with a precursor charge or tandem warhead. It also offers some degree of protection against explosviely formed penetrators (EFPs) and APFSDS, however only against older types. 
The tiles of both ERAWA and ERAWA-2 have a size of 150 x 150 militmetres. ERAWA has a thickness of 26 mm and weighs 2.9 kg. It contains of one single but rather thick reactive element consisting of steel plates and explosive located inside a steel casette mounted on bolts.
The multilayer ERAWA-2 ERA utilizes a thicker tile of 46 mm containing two reactive elements. The coverplate is thicker and might include a non-metallic composite content. This leads to a weight of 4.7 kg per tile.

Polish BMP with CERAWA-1 ERA
CERAWA is a prototype type of ERA based on ERAWA, but designed to incorporate a ceramic tile into the reactive element instead of mainly relying on metalic materials like steel. The reactive element still contains a certain amount of steel though and is also making use of rubber in some applications. CERAWA provides protection against classic (small) RPGs, which have a penetration into steel in the range of 300 milimetres, and 14.5 mm armor-piercing ammunition when fitted to a BMP-1. Unlike other types of ERA, CERAWA does not require a large amount of base armor: in Polish trials, a 10 mm steel plate was neither penetrated by a RPG-7 nor by the CERAWA explosive reactive armor protecting it.

Switzerland's RUAG has developed SidePRO-CE, which is a composite explosive reactive armor design. The focus for SidePRO-CE was put on lower collateral damage. SidePRO-CE does provide protection against HEAT ammunition such as RPGs (incl. tandem shaped charge warheads) and kinetic energy ammunition.

SidePRO-CE ERA being tested against a HEAT warhead.
CLARA (Composite Lightweight Adaptable Reactive Armour) is a German composite reactive armor, which has been developed by Dynamit Nobel Defence (a company that traces back it's origin to Alfred Nobel, aka "that guy from the Nobel prize" and inventor of the dynamite). Unlike other types of ERA, CLARA is designed to be fragmentation free. This is achieved by using a composite fibre material instead of metal or ceramic plates for the reactive elements.
Depending on version CLARA has an areal density of 70 kilograms per metre to 270 kilograms per metre. It provides protection against single stage shaped charges (as used on most RPGs), EFPs and in case of the heavy version against kinetic energy penetrators up to 30 mm APFSDS. 

CLARA was originally developed for the Dutch-German Fennek scout car deployed in Afghanistan, but it was never adopted on the Fennek due to weight concerns and changes in priorities. After being successfully trialed on the Marder infantry fighting vehicle (IFV), CLARA is being used to protect the German Puma IFV in certain areas. In this configuration, each ERA tile has a weight of about 40 kilograms. It has also been tested on the Boxer APC. According to Dynamit Nobel Defence CLARA offers a tenfold increase in protection per weight compared to "traditional passive armor", the latter is understood to be steel armor.

24 comments:

  1. Hi,

    thank you very much for this article, it is great and very interesting.

    However, everybody knows that Tandem-HEAT was designed to overcome the first ERA models. Now I often read that modern ERA can maintain some effectiveness against Tandem-HEAT and APFSDS designed to overcome ERA like the russian K-5. So I am very curious and intrigued on how it supposed to be done. It would be awesome if you could write an article on that topic.

    Again thank you very much and wish you the best

    Kinds regards

    Juan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Don Juan, I actually have the same question about the effectiveness of tandem-HEAT deal with various type of ERA & NERA.

      Delete
    2. Es ist eigentlich ganz einfach, gegen Tandem HEAT nutzt man eine Metallplatte die die Raektivpanzerung vor der ersten Detonation schützt so das sie nicht ausgelöst wird und gegen APFSDS hilft sie da sie das Projektil destabilisiert und es somit nicht mehr effektiv auf die Panzerung trifft.(Ähnlich dem Prinzip beim Leopard1 A1 welcher am Turm Metall "Kegel" sitzen hat welche den Dart ablenken sollen )

      Delete
  2. hi
    There,
    Thank you for sharing a knowledgeable blog with us I hope that you will post many more blog with us:

    The need of Medieval armour in 21st century is figured out in historical events, drama, shows, casting of tv serials, and many other similar occasions. If you’re looking to cast a show where dressing up like a real medieval knight is the need of hours, here is the right suggestion. Indian Medieval armour is an online store of real Medieval armour. We have special Medieval armour for sale Germany discounts for those who want to order them in bulk.

    Click here:medieval armour for sale

    ReplyDelete
  3. Moreover, the demand for Ballistic Steel in UAE extends to the field of building protection. Critical infrastructure, government facilities, and commercial establishments often require fortified structures to mitigate security risks. Armoring steel is employed in constructing blast-resistant walls, doors, and windows, providing an additional layer of protection against forced entry, ballistic attacks, and explosions. This ensures the safety of occupants and the preservation of vital assets.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Convenience is another factor that Tablet Repair Davie takes seriously. They understand that your schedule is busy, and they work diligently to provide a hassle-free experience. Whether you have a minor glitch or a major hardware problem, their dedicated team treats each repair with professionalism and attention to detail, ensuring that your tablet is in capable hands.

    ReplyDelete
  5. For those who appreciate a waterfront lifestyle, New Condos for Sale Etobicoke location along Lake Ontario offers a unique opportunity. Some new condo developments provide stunning lakefront views, along with access to waterfront parks and trails, creating a serene atmosphere within the bustling city. These waterfront condos provide a harmonious blend of natural beauty and urban vibrancy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Efficiency is a key consideration in EV charging systems, and EV Charging Dc-Dc Converter Manufacturer play a pivotal role in maintaining this efficiency. By utilizing modern power electronics and control algorithms, these converters can achieve high efficiency levels, minimizing energy losses during the conversion process. This is essential in ensuring that the energy from the main battery is used effectively and that the overall charging process is as energy-efficient as possible.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Remeha Avanta E4 stands as a testament to the commitment of Remeha to provide efficient and reliable heating solutions. The integration of such diagnostic codes into their boiler systems underscores the manufacturer's dedication to ensuring that their products not only perform well but are also easy to maintain and service.

    ReplyDelete
  8. A Salesforce Partner Manchester plays a pivotal role in helping businesses maximize the benefits of the Salesforce ecosystem. Salesforce, as a leading Customer Relationship Management (CRM) platform, offers a wide range of solutions for sales, marketing, customer service, and more. Companies in Manchester turn to Salesforce Partners to navigate the complexity of the platform, implement tailored solutions, and ensure a seamless integration into their existing business processes.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Moreover, Landscape Rock Delivery often come with professional assistance, guiding customers in choosing the appropriate rocks for their projects. Experts can advise on the best rock types based on the landscape design, color scheme, and intended use, ensuring that the chosen rocks complement the overall aesthetic of the outdoor space.

    ReplyDelete
  10. One of the exciting aspects of Piano Lesson Singapore is the progression of skills. Beginners start with simple tunes and gradually advance to more complex compositions. This progression instills a sense of achievement and motivates students to practice and improve. Over time, students gain the ability to interpret and perform diverse musical pieces, enhancing their artistic expression and musical interpretation skills.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Moreover, Party Limo rental South Florida understands the importance of creating lasting memories for their clients. They take pride in providing not just a mode of transportation, but an experience that enhances the overall enjoyment of any event or occasion. Their professional chauffeurs are not only skilled drivers, but also courteous and attentive professionals who go the extra mile to ensure that your experience is nothing short of exceptional.

    ReplyDelete
  12. One of the benefits of Gel Nail Polish Online is that it tends to be more gentle on the nails and cuticles. Since it doesn't require the use of acetone or other harsh chemicals for removal, it can be a preferred option for those with sensitive nails or individuals who want to minimize their exposure to chemical solvents.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Bronze Memorial Duquesne is evident in the memorial's intricate details, from precisely carved inscriptions to thoughtfully integrated bronze elements. The combination of granite and bronze adds a touch of visual sophistication and personalization, allowing for a unique representation of the stories and legacies of the individuals memorialized in Duquesne. Each element contributes to a narrative that preserves the essence of those who have played a vital role in shaping the community.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The Palm Dubai Hotels are not just accommodations; they are immersive experiences. Lavish spa facilities, pristine private beaches, and infinity pools offer moments of relaxation and rejuvenation against the stunning Dubai backdrop. For those with an inclination for adventure, the hotels can arrange water sports, desert safaris, or exclusive access to some of Dubai's most iconic attractions.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The menu at a typical Boston Bubble Tea Delivery is a fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors. Customers can choose from a variety of tea bases, including classic black or green tea, fruit-infused options, or even creamy milk teas. What sets bubble tea apart is the addition of chewy tapioca pearls, also known as "bubbles" or "boba," which adds a delightful texture to each sip. Beyond the traditional pearls, many shops also offer an array of other toppings, such as fruit jellies, aloe vera, or even ice cream, allowing patrons to tailor their beverages to their unique tastes.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The design of Vibrating Screen can vary based on the specific requirements of the application. Factors such as the desired capacity, particle size distribution, and the type of material being processed influence the design and configuration of the screen. Advanced technologies and innovations continue to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of vibrating screens, making them indispensable equipment in various industrial processes.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The marketing and distribution strategies employed by Designer Perfume brands play a pivotal role in shaping their success and visibility in the marketplace. Fashion houses and luxury brands leverage their global presence, retail partnerships, and digital platforms to create buzz, generate excitement, and drive sales for their fragrance offerings. From high-profile advertising campaigns and celebrity endorsements to exclusive launch events and immersive brand experiences, designers employ a multi-faceted approach to engage consumers, build brand loyalty, and establish their fragrances as must-have accessories in the competitive world of luxury goods.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Kenmore's commitment to sustainability echoes in Roof Repairing Services Kenmore WA. Professionals often introduce eco-friendly solutions, such as cool roofing materials that reflect sunlight and contribute to energy efficiency. This dual focus on durability and environmental consciousness aligns with the city's ethos, creating roofs that not only withstand the elements but also contribute to the overall eco-friendly profile of Kenmore homes.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Another important aspect of Commercial Bingsu Machine is their durability and reliability, especially in commercial settings where they may be subjected to frequent use and heavy demand. Manufacturers design these machines to withstand continuous operation and rigorous conditions, using high-quality materials and components that are built to last. Regular maintenance and servicing are also essential to ensure the longevity and optimal performance of Bingsu machines over time.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Moreover, Women's Short Sleeve T Shirts
    serve as conversation starters and icebreakers, sparking interactions and connections with others. Whether it's a compliment on a witty slogan or a shared laugh over a humorous phrase, these shirts have a way of bringing people together and fostering a sense of camaraderie and community.

    ReplyDelete
  21. In addition to plant selection, Landscaping in Colorado Springs emphasizes water conservation through the use of efficient irrigation systems and techniques. This includes drip irrigation, rainwater harvesting, and smart irrigation controllers that adjust watering schedules based on weather conditions. By minimizing water waste and promoting efficient water use, green landscaping helps preserve Colorado's limited water resources and reduces the environmental impact of outdoor water consumption.

    ReplyDelete