Donnerstag, 22. Dezember 2016

Marders to Jordan

Jordan has received an initial batch of 16 ex-German Marder infantry fighting vehicles (IFVs) on the 11th December of 2016 as part of German military aid. The delivery also included 20 mm RH202 autocannons, spare parts and a Marder driver training vehicle. It must be noted that the permission for an export of 24 Marders, 28 Rh 202 autocannons and one Marder driver training vehicle to Jordan was given for 2016. The costs of this equipment is €12.8 million. This means that most likely a second batch of Marders will be shipped this year. A total of 50 Marder IFVs are being delivered to Jordan until end of 2017. Furthermore Jordan is set to receive surveillance equipment, 56 vans and 70 trucks.
The military aid to Jordan is part of a bigger initiative, which costs about €100 million in 2016 and €130 million in 2017. Other recipients of the German military aid are the Iraq, Tunesia, Mali, Nigeria and Niger. Jordan received about €25 million from the German government in order to be able to purchase the Marders.

Marder 1A3s being handed over to the Jordanian Army
The Marder IFV is an older design, being introduced into German Army service in 1971. It replaced the HS.30 Schützenpanzer lang, the first infantry fighting vehicle of the world. While offering only average firepower for it's time, the Marder was designed to feature a higher degree of armor protection, being heavier than all other IFV counterparts of the same era.

The Marder 1A3 is fitted with spaced applique armor, even at the roof

The engine cover of the Marder has a thickness of 11 mm, which together with the slope of 78° leads to an effective thickness of 53 milimetres. Supposedly the rest of the upper hull front is slightly thicker at 15 mm. The lower hull front has a thickness of 32 mm sloped at 24°, leading to a thickness of 35 mm from the front. The side armor is only 15 mm thick, but sloped at the upper part and covered behind the sideskirts at the lower sections. The armor of the low-profile turret is 25 mm thick at the front, which due to the 40° slope results in a line of sight thickness of 33 mm.

Marder 1A3 turret after being hit by 30 mm ammunition
Jordan received the Marder 1A3 variant, which can be identified by the thicker armor, but still features the old sideskirts with a wave-pattern. This version features no additional mine protection plate, which seems to be a miscalculation, based on how improvised explosive devices (IEDs) and mines are commonly used by insurgents and terrorists.
The main change in the Marder 1A3 compared to earlier versions is a further layer of spaced armor being fitted to the front, sides and also the roof. This raised the weight of the vehicle by about 5.5 metric tons. The exact protection level of this armor is unknown, but it has been tested against 30 mm ammunition (either AP or APDS) fired from 400 metres distance without any penetration of the main armor. The sides are resistant against 14.5 mm AP ammunition fired from short ranges.

The Mader 1A3 upgrade entered service in 1989
The exact thickness of the add-on armor is still unknown, but it's frontal add-on plate is estimated to be about 7 to 10 mm thick. The add-on armor is spaced several centimetres apart form the base armor, the steel stand-offs include a special rubber padding. This allows the armor to be a lot more effective than just a single layer of steel with equal thickness. Unlike many other combat vehicles such as the Bradley and Warrior, the Marder's armor upgrade also enhanced the roof protection.

The biggest downside of the Marder is the firepower. While being rather well armed in the 1970s and still very acceptable in the 1980s, the lack of firepower upgrades has worsened the situation. The Marder has no fire on the move capability and hunter/killer capability, two features that were added to the M2A3 Bradley in the late 1990s. The 20 mm Rh 202 autocannon of the Marder was still capable of defeating the Soviet-designed BMP-1, BMP-2 and BMP-3 at 1,000 metres or more using the APDS ammunition.

Currently all Marders are armed with the Rh 202 gun
The original upgrade proposal of the German industry that lead to the Marder 1A3 also featured a 25 mm autocannon and a 720 hp engine, but neither of these features were not adopted by the German Army. A main reason for this the development of a Marder successor, starting with the Marder 2 infantry fighting vehicle developed in the late 1980s. The development of the Marder 2 was started in 1984 (first requirements), the first prototype was delivered in 1991. The collapse of the Soviet Union however meant a re-thinking of the German defence doctrine, which lead to the cancellation of the Marder 2. After the Marder 2 project was ended, the requirements for a new IFV were incorporated in the Neue Gepanzerte Plattform (NGP, "new armored platform") in 1996. While the original NGP was meant to include a modular chassis for all tracked combat vehicles (including main battle tanks, recovery vehicles, self-propelled guns, etc.), all of them were canceled except for the IFV. The IFV version of the NGP then became - after numerous design and requirement changes, reducing the maximum weight by 45% - the current Puma IFV. In German service the Marder 1 is currently being replaced by the Puma IFV, it entered service in 2014.

The Marder 2 was the first IFV with hunter/killer capabilty and ceramic armor
Meanwhile Germany has decided to upgrade a small amount of Marders as a result of cuts to the Puma order (reduced from 410 to 350 vehicles) and production delays (most of which are result of modifying the Puma's design to meet new requirements). The upgrade is scheduled to include new thermal imagers for 200 Marders and the MELLS (multi-role guided missile system), a version of the Israeli SPIKE-LR anti-tank guided missile.
The Marder has been exported to Chile and Indonesia. 237 Marders were sold to Chile, while Indonesia bought only 50. A sale of more than 400 Marder 1A3 IFVs to Greece failed due to the international finance crisis. Tunesia is scheduled for receiving the Marder infantry fighting vehicles in an unknown quantity.

Aside of the planned German Army upgrades to optronics and missile system, a number of further upgrade options are available for the Marder. A very simple upgrade option is replacing the turret with an off-the-shelf turret design for enhanced firepower. KUKA, now a part of Rheinmetall, offered the M12 with Mauser 30 mm autocannon for the Marder in the late 1990s. Furthermore a number of different turrets have been tested on the Marder during the 1970s to 1990s.


The protection can be enhanced by installing add-on armor, the Marder still should have enough weight left for this. Two types of explosive reactive armor, the French BRENUS and the German CLARA designs, have been tested on the Marder. Alternatively slat armor or lightweight composite armor such as RUAG's SidePRO-RPG could be fitted to the Marder, if needed (Germany considered slat armor a bad solution and has rejcted the use of it). The Active Defence System (ADS) developed by IBD Deisenroth in cooperation with Rheinmetall has been tested on the Marder 1A5.

The Marder CCV is fitted with an unmanned Lance-RC turret
More complex upgrades inlcude the Marder CCV, which was developed for Canada's close combat vehicle (CCV) requirement. This variant is fitted with thick layers of AMAP composite armor, a remotely-controlled Lance-RC turret with Wotan 30 mm chain gun, an air conditioning unit and an upgraded engine. The Marder CCV has not been purchased by any country yet.

The Lynx is apparently based on the Marder's hull
The new Lynx family of combat is believed to be based on the Marder 1A3. More specifcially, the Marder hull is used as the base of the Lynx, but essentially all internal components are replaced by Rheinmetall. The powerpack is changed, the tracks are replaced, a new turret is fitted, some armor elements are replaced. the Lynx also includes modern computer systems and optics.
The IFV variant of the Lynx is fitted with a two-men Lance modular turret armed with either a Wotan 30 mm or 35 mm chain gun. These guns have a magnetic coil for firing Rheinmetall's suite of programmable ammunition. Furthermore the turret can be fitted with a remote weapon station (RWS) slaved to the commander's main optic and a dual-launcher for SPIKE-LR ATGMs. The Lynx has been offered to Australia as part of the LAND 400 program.

Kommentare:

  1. Great article, do you know if the Marder 1a3 composite could resist a RPG-7 to the frontal arc?

    AntwortenLöschen
    Antworten
    1. Probably not, but it depends on what warhead you are using for the RPG.

      Löschen
    2. The RPG protection measure is been mentioned in the article. There are 2 different add-on armor would be used for against RPG type weapon. Traditional ERA or RUAG's SidePRO-RPG (passive composite armor) which both are specifically dealt with HEAT threat. SidePRO-RPG had been proved against even more powerful 90mm RPG-7VL warhead.

      Löschen
    3. No, the basic Marder 1A3 cannot resist a RPG-7. One German Marder 1A5 (1A3 + mine protection kit) was destroyed by a RPG in Afghanistan.

      Löschen
  2. However there is probably a mistake, when you assume that there is enough weight left to upgrade the 1A3. As a former soldier on the 1A5 I can tell you that the engine and gearbox or overall the power pack was struggling already with the added weight from the 1A5 and from what I see they are missing the external APU and air-conditioning which should be necessary for them due the operating climate.
    A upgrade to the power pack should be welcomed to get more out of the Marder actually.

    However I could be wrong when I recall my gunner training, but fighting around 1000m is already the maximum optimal range for the 20mm, albeit could be slightly higher but not by a lot.

    Cheers guys

    AntwortenLöschen
    Antworten
    1. Could protection maybe be increased by adding active protection instead of Armour?

      Löschen
    2. A while back IBD presented their APS with a Marder actually, however the file has restricted access and there is only a small picture of it which made it out to the public.

      As mentioned from MM there are options to improve the Marder in several aspects, the question is if it is worth it for their usage.

      I would assume that KADDB might improve the Marder with the help of Rheinmetall or someone else

      Löschen
    3. The KF31 Lynx IFV from Rheinmetall is supposed to use an unmodified Marder suspension and can handle up to 38 tons.

      Löschen
  3. Btw, how many Marders are avaialable? (ie not needed by the German army but not scrapped or otherwise disposed)

    AntwortenLöschen
    Antworten
    1. Not very much, most were scrapped. Exact data is unfortunately hard to obtain.

      Löschen
  4. Greeks had offers from the Germans for the Marder1A3 from 2003 time period. The offers were very expensive for an old vehicle like the Marder1A3, with nothing else to offer other than increased operating cost for the Greeks and money for the Germans. Marder1A3 can not protect Greek infantry from 25X137 ammo the Turkish AIFV fires, or from Eryx missile they use or even M72 LAW and RPG-7 they also use. Marder1A3 is a relic of the cold war not suited for Greek needs. But German companies insist on making offers to the Greeks, about a possible Marder1A3 sale even now.

    AntwortenLöschen
    Antworten
    1. Well the Marder is not bad by any means but without any modifications like the M12 Kuka or some of the AMAP upgrades besides an upgraded power pack it is of course not suitable anymore. Been really surprised that countries still buy it.

      We just had too much of them during the cold war in comparison to how small the mech inf. Is by now.....

      Löschen
    2. Marder 1A3 can resist 25 mm ammunition at normal ranges -s pecifically Turkish ammunition, because they still use old APDS rounds and no APFSDS ammunition.

      Löschen